Best Local Coffee Shops on Long Island

Long Island’s got charm — beaches, boutiques, and yes, some seriously good coffee. Whether you’re house-hunting in Port Jefferson, exploring Huntington Village, or soaking up the Hamptons sun, finding a local coffee shop that hits just right is a total game-changer.

We’re sharing some of the best coffee shops across Long Island — spots that deliver caffeine, community, and the kind of vibe that makes a neighborhood feel like home. Bonus: These picks are all near some of our favorite new construction homes, so you can sip and scout at the same time.

📍 1. Southdown Coffee – Huntington, Glen Cove, Northport

This North Shore staple is a go-to for serious coffee drinkers. Southdown roasts single-origin beans and serves them in cozy-modern spaces filled with local charm. Their cold brew is bold, and the matcha specials rotate with the seasons — always worth a try.

🌐 Website: southdowncoffee.com

📍 2. Flux Coffee – Farmingdale

Minimalist interior, major flavor. Flux is all about clean lines and bold brews, with beans roasted on-site for max freshness. It's perfect for a remote work session or a quick espresso hit before hopping on the LIRR.

📸 Instagram: @fluxcoffee

📍 3. Hard Bean Coffee – Merrick

This South Shore gem brings cozy vibes and community energy. Hard Bean serves up classic lattes, smoothies, pastries, and warm service — a must-visit if you’re exploring homes in Merrick or Bellmore.

📸 Instagram: @hardbeancoffeemerrick

📍 4. Toast Coffeehouse – Patchogue, Bay Shore, Port Jeff, Long Beach

Toast does more than just coffee — it’s a full brunch mood. Think: house-made syrup lattes, cozy interiors, and major comfort food. If you’re touring homes nearby, this is your post-walk pick-me-up.

🌐 Website: toastcoffeehouse.com

📍 5. For Five Coffee Roasters – Manhasset + Garden City

Originally born in NYC, For Five brings upscale café culture to the Island with sleek interiors, rotating seasonal drinks, and a next-level food menu. Don’t skip the lavender oat milk latte or the Nutella croissant.

🌐 Website: forfivecoffee.com

☕ Why Local Coffee Shops Matter When House Hunting

Sure, there’s always a Starbucks nearby. But local coffee shops? They’re where the real community lives. It's where neighbors catch up, remote workers post up, and newcomers get a taste of the local flavor — literally.

💡 Pro House-Hunting Tip When you’re touring homes in a new area, always stop by the local coffee shop. You’ll get a vibe check on the neighborhood fast. And if you’re buying new construction, check the area for those walkable, latte-worthy spots that turn a house into a lifestyle.

🏡 Looking for New Construction Homes Near These Coffee Shops? We’ve got the listings — new homes across Long Island in walkable, café-filled neighborhoods. ➡️ Explore New Construction Homes on Long Island

Because let’s be real… your morning coffee deserves a kitchen island and a front porch to match.

📲 Follow us on socials for more Long Island lifestyle tips, listings & builder exclusives!

• Instagram: @mylestonehome

• TikTok: @mylestonehome